3 Best Backpacking Shoes

How we test hiking shoes

We gather fact-checked data and put backpacking shoes through a series of tests to come up with honest reviews. The details of our approach are as follows:

• We buy every pair of hiking shoes with our own money.
• We spend days trekking on a variety of terrain in both dry and wet conditions to test each kick.
• To make our backpacking shoe reviews more comprehensive, we gather data by measuring different parameters. In the process, we also split the shoes in half. We analyze the results and compare them to averages. 

When to use backpacking shoes

When you’re going backpacking over not-too-demanding terrain, usually on 1-2 day trips. When the hike becomes very serious, the terrain uneven and technical, maybe it lasts a few days, and you’re wearing a very heavy backpack, best to go for backpacking boots. A bit easier trails can be covered in backpacking shoes as long as you’re OK with not having that ankle support that only boots give. 

3 features that make backpacking shoes stand out

In all hiking shoes, we recommend looking for the protection and grip you need for the hike ahead. In backpacking shoes, it is imperative to look for: 

1. Average or firmer midsoles. Too soft and your feet will sink in, there might be not enough response, which results in premature foot fatigue to start with (best case scenario). 
2. Average or stiffer platforms. This is important because shoes that are too flexible can tire you out and not offer the support you need from the footwear. Also, stiffer shoes bend less over technical terrain. 
3. Stability! It’s all about not twisting your ankles and feeling secure on the hike. We examine the lateral stability and measure the width of the base: wider bases are more stable than the narrow, tall ones. 

Thanks to our standardized lab tests and extensive wear tests, we’re able to cover all of these features in great detail and back them up with our lab data down below. 

Nail the fit in backpacking shoes

If this is not your first time buying hiking shoes, feel free to skip this section.

If you’re new to hiking, we strongly recommend sticking to these guidelines: 

• Go shopping later in the day, in the evening or in the afternoon. We’re aiming for swollen feet, something that naturally happens towards the end of the day, and also when hiking. 
• Bring your hiking socks with you. Orthotics as well, if you’re using them. 
• Put the shoes on and make sure there’s one thumb’s width of space behind your heel when you push the foot forward. 
• Test the shoes on the ramp, if there is one. It’s usually covered with different materials like artificial grass, pebbles, and rocks. Go up and down.
• There should be no heel slipping. 
• Your feet should not be sliding to the sides inside the shoe. 
• The shoes should be comfortable: not too snug and not too wide! 

Before the first hike, especially if it’s a long one, make sure to brake in these shoes properly. 

Firmer midsoles: a must 

For backpacking, firmer midsoles are better than softer midsoles. The firmer ones offer more support and are more protective. Softer ones can bottom out and cause pain in your feet and lower legs, especially if your backpack is very heavy. 

Testing the softness of the midsole on the test hike

To examine the softness, we press a durometer into the midsole of a shoe we’ve cut in half. The lower the number on it, the softer the midsole. 

Why stiffer platforms are better for backpacking

Flexible footwear is better because it allows a more natural foot movement. However, when backpacking, you’re carrying a backpack and you might be covering terrain covered with rocks, debris, or simply a lot of uphills and downhills. In this case, it is better to hike in stiffer shoes. They don’t allow that much of the movement and that actually feels supportive. 

In the lab, we measure the stiffness of the shoes by pushing them to the 90-degree angle and measuring the force it took us to do that. The greater the force, the stiffer the platform. 

Measuring the stiffness of the hiking shoe in RunRepeat lab using a digital force gauge

We don’t stop there. We also assess the torsional rigidity! Those that are scored 5/5 are as rigid as it gets, unlike those that score 1/5 (most flexible). 

Assessing the torsional rigidity of a backpacking shoe

Stability to the MAX!

Stability matters a lot when pebbles, rocks, debris, roots, and any other obstacles come into the equation. No one wants a twisted ankle. When doing test hikes, we always check the lateral stability: how the backpacking shoe feels and performs. 

Lateral stability check on the test hike

But, what we can actually measure here, is the width of the platform. When a hiking shoe has a tall and narrow platform, it’s a great recipe for disaster. Fortunately, that is not often the case. But, we’d want it wider and, therefore, more stable. 

Even heel counters can be stiff! 

Some hikers might not enjoy this, but if you like that extra supportive feel, look for a stiff heel counter. 

We examine it by squeezing it and pushing it while in our lab. We give it a 1-5 rating, where 5 is the stiffest. 

Assessing the stiffness of the heel counter in a backpacking shoe

Durability of backpacking shoes

Durability is always an important feature in footwear. In hiking, however, it’s not only about how long will the backpacking shoe last, but also: 

• The durability of the toebox tells us how much protection the toebox offers for our toes. The debris we encounter on the hike or that falls accidentally on the toebox should not hurt our toes. 
• The durability of the outsole tells us not just how long will the grip (the lugs) last, but how protective it is. The denser and harder outsoles are less likely to be destroyed by sharp objects on the trails.
• The durability of the heel counter, just like in any other shoe, tells us how long until that part is left with no materials to cushion the heel or at least will it wear out sooner or later. 

Pressing a Dremel on the upper to test the durability of the toebox

For these durability tests, we use a Dremel. We press it against the material and note down the damage. When testing the upper, we assess the damage on a 1-5 scale, where 1 is the least durable. 

When testing the heel counter, it is the same - we rate it on a 1-5 scale, and 5 is a dream come true: the most durable one. 

When testing the durability of the upper, we can actually measure the damage using a tire tread gauge. 

Pressing a Dremel against the hiking shoe outsole to test its durability

We measure the dent made by the Dremel and, the larger it is, the less durable the outsole rubber. 

Look for superb grip and don’t settle for less than that

Slipping, sliding, rolling… to prevent that, it’s best to look for the shoe that will offer a brutal grip on the terrain you’re covering.

Here’s what we suggest: 

1. If hiking in wet weather, meaning there’s mud, slush, snow, look for backpacking shoes with very deep lugs (4mm or deeper). 
2. If hiking on large, flat rocks (or very hard ground), look for shallower lugs. Such shoes will hurt your feet less, and shallower harder lugs will last longer on such terrain than the soft large lugs. We’re talking about a depth of up to 4mm. 
3. For anything in between or a bit of everything but nothing too extreme, look for average lugs (around 4mm). 

In all our reviews, you can find the exact depth of the lugs and how it compares to the averages. We use a digital caliper to measure how thick the lugs are. 

Keep in mind though, that, the grip is not only about the thickness of the lugs, but also the hardness of the rubber. The harder rubber is more protective, while softer rubber is stickier. We also measure this in our lab. 

Wide toebox in backpacking shoes

Given that backpacking usually entails multi-day hikes or, at least, long mileage over 1 day, your feet will swell and that means you might need more room there. Or, you actually have wider feet that ask for a wider toebox. 

No worries because in our lab, we measure the width of the toebox, which it's the widest, and around the big toe. Both measurements are important because there are different shapes of toes out there. But, the smaller the big toe number, the more the shoe tapers. Or, it’s more pointy. 

Breathability of backpacking shoes

If hiking in summer, you want to know about this. If hiking in winter, same, but then you also want to know about waterproofing (next chapter). 

In the lab, we examine the breathability by pumping the smoke into the shoe and looking at the smoke coming out: does it come out, where it comes out, at which pace and how much of it. 

Non-breathable hiking shoe (left) and a breathable one (right) on the smoke test

In breathable hiking shoes, we see it come out through the upper and the sides. In less breathable shoes (or not breathable at all), it might come out through the eyelets only. Based on these, we rate the breathability on a 1-5 scale, where 1 is the least breathable. 

We also examined the upper under the microscope, and we noticed how the breathable uppers have a looser structure, while the non-breathable ones have a very tight, dense structure. 

Shoes that have their breathability rated as 1 or 2 are great for cold temperatures because the heat will not escape outside. The shoes rated with 4 or 5 in breathability are great for summer because they turned out to be quite breezy. 

Best backpacking shoes for winter

In winter, it's not just about the breathability. As mentioned above, backpacking shoes we find winter-friendly are those that score low on the breathability test (rating of 1 or 2) because they are not ventilated enough, which means the heat stays trapped inside. 

But, what's also important is whether, at freezing temperatures, the backpacking shoe performs similarly to when it's at room temp. Meaning: does the shoe feel like a brick when it's very cold? No one wants that! 

Here's how we examine this. First, we put the shoe in the freezer for 20 minutes. Then we test its flexibility and softness again and compare the numbers to those measured at the room temp. Smaller differences in % mean that the shoe does not change its performance and feel much. Very big differences in % should be a sort of a red flag. 

When to use waterproof backpacking shoes

Only when you know you will actually need them: you plan to hike over very wet grass or there might be some rain on the hike. 

Pros of using waterproof backpacking shoes: 

• Your feet will stay dry if you encounter some wet areas or wet weather 
• Used with waterproof gaiters, these shoes can do wonders in terms of waterproofing! The gaiters will keep your lower legs and ankles dry as well, and they wonderfully prevent the water (slush, mud) from getting into the shoes. 

Cons of using waterproof backpacking shoes: 

• These shoes don’t breathe, so your feet might sweat more than usual 
• It’s easy for water to get into your shoes as it might slide down your legs/trousers, or the water area might be too deep, so the water gets in through the eyelets or simply over the heel counter
• If the water gets in somehow, blisters are the best-case scenario (the water can’t get out)

Waterproof hiking shoes are easy to recognize, either they have the popular Gore-Tex (GTX) membrane, or they are clearly marked as Waterproof. 

You might be ok with hiking shoes that are only water-resistant or water-repellent. In that case, no need to invest in waterproof material. Here’s how to make that decision based on the weather conditions: 

If you decide to use waterproof shoes, we advise also getting wool or bamboo socks. They have moisture-wicking features and tend to keep you warm when it’s cold and cold when it’s warm.